Do you really need a cupboard full of supplements to get you through perimenopause and menopause? Probably not.
There are so many supplements marketed at women going through perimenopause and menopause. From gummies and powders to capsules promising better sleep, more energy, fewer hot flushes and improved mood, it can be difficult to know what’s worth taking and what’s simply clever marketing.
I was really interested to see a recent article from Which? looking at this very subject, alongside comments from Dr Chris van Tulleken on BBC Radio 2. Both highlighted something I regularly discuss with my patients: there is very little good evidence to support the use of most menopause-specific supplements.
And that’s important, because when you’re not feeling yourself and you’re trying to find something to help, it’s easy to be drawn in by products promising to make everything better.
So, what do you actually need?
Do menopause supplements actually work?
Which? reviewed 26 popular supplements marketed for perimenopause, menopause and women over 45, looking at more than 80 different active ingredients.
Their findings were interesting. There was little consistent evidence to support many of the ingredients used, and many products were essentially standard multivitamins with a few added herbal ingredients.
Some of these botanical ingredients were included in such small amounts that they were unlikely to have much effect. Others have some research behind them, but the evidence isn’t strong or consistent enough to recommend them routinely.
The other thing that stood out was the price. Adding words like ‘peri’ or ‘menopause’ to a product can make it considerably more expensive, even when the ingredients are very similar to a standard multivitamin.
The reality is that most women don’t need a special menopause supplement.
Vitamin D and menopause: Why it’s worth taking in Scotland
If there’s one supplement I’d encourage people living in Scotland to consider, it’s vitamin D.
We don’t get enough sunlight for our bodies to make sufficient vitamin D during the winter months, and it’s difficult to get everything we need from food alone.
Vitamin D helps our bodies absorb calcium and plays an important role in keeping our bones and muscles healthy.
The advice is for everyone in the UK to consider taking a daily supplement containing 10 micrograms (400 IU) of vitamin D between October and March. Some people may need it all year round, depending on their circumstances.
You don’t need an expensive product or a menopause-branded version. A straightforward vitamin D supplement from your pharmacy or supermarket is absolutely fine.
Calcium and menopause: Looking after your bone health
Calcium is another nutrient worth paying attention to as you approach and go through menopause.
Oestrogen helps protect our bones. As oestrogen levels fall, bone loss can speed up, increasing the risk of developing osteoporosis later in life.
Calcium is essential for maintaining strong bones, so it’s important to make sure you’re getting enough.
Ideally, this should come from your diet. Good sources include:
- Milk, cheese and yoghurt.
- Calcium-fortified plant-based milks.
- Green leafy vegetables such as broccoli and cabbage.
- Tofu.
- Nuts and seeds.
- Fish where you eat the bones, such as sardines.
Most adults should be able to get the calcium they need through a varied, balanced diet. If you’re not getting enough, a calcium supplement may be worth considering. It’s not something everyone automatically needs to take.
Are menopause-branded supplements worth the extra money?
One thing that really stood out in the Which? review was just how much more expensive some supplements become when they’re marketed specifically for perimenopause or menopause.
You might see products promising to help with everything from hot flushes and sleep to energy, mood and brain fog. But look at the ingredients and you may find they’re little different from an ordinary multivitamin, sometimes with a few additional ingredients thrown in.
There isn’t good evidence to show that these specialist blends are more effective than standard supplements. And paying more doesn’t mean you’re getting something better.
If you want to take a multivitamin, a basic one from your pharmacy or supermarket is generally a sensible choice. But remember, if you’re eating a varied diet and don’t have a specific deficiency, you may not need one at all.
This article isn’t intended to dismiss every natural or herbal approach to menopause. Some women are interested in exploring these options, and there is a separate discussion to be had about the evidence for individual remedies, their potential benefits and their safety. You can read more in our guide to natural remedies for menopause symptoms.
What should you focus on instead during perimenopause and menopause?
Rather than spending lots of money on supplements, I’d encourage you to look at your diet and overall health.
Two things I’d particularly focus on are protein and fibre.
Protein helps maintain muscle mass, which becomes increasingly important as we get older. Include good sources such as eggs, fish, chicken, dairy, beans, lentils, tofu and other plant-based proteins.
Fibre supports gut and digestive health. Aim to include plenty of vegetables, fruit, wholegrains, pulses, nuts and seeds in your diet.
A varied diet with enough protein, fibre, vitamins and minerals will provide most of what your body needs. And alongside nutrition, regular exercise – particularly strength and weight-bearing exercise – is important for maintaining muscle and bone health.
Still not feeling yourself? It might not be a supplement you need.
I completely understand why women try so many different supplements during perimenopause and menopause. When you’re struggling with symptoms and not feeling like yourself, you want to do something to help.
But spending a fortune on products that have little evidence behind them isn’t necessarily going to make you feel better.
If you’re experiencing symptoms such as poor sleep, low mood, hot flushes, fatigue or any number of less talked about symptoms, it’s worth looking at what’s actually causing them and what treatment or support might help.
For some women, that may include HRT. For others, it could be lifestyle changes, support with specific symptoms or investigating another underlying cause.
You don’t have to work it all out yourself.
At The Women’s Clinic in Edinburgh, we offer longer, unhurried appointments to understand what’s going on, talk through your symptoms and help you make informed decisions about your health.
If you’re taking a cupboard full of supplements and still not feeling right, let’s look at what might actually help.





